The day after President Donald Trump’s inauguration, a shock customer joined the group outdoors the D.C. Jail, drawing double takes as folks acknowledged his signature eyepatch: Stewart Rhodes, founding father of the far-right Oath Keepers motion.
By the chilly math of the justice system, Rhodes was not alleged to be there. He’d gone to sleep the night time earlier than in a Maryland jail cell, the place he was serving 18 years as a convicted ringleader of the assault on the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021. The Yale-educated firebrand who as soon as boasted a nationwide paramilitary community had seen his group collapse underneath prosecution.
For the Justice Division, Rhodes’ seditious conspiracy conviction was larger than crushing the Oath Keepers — it was a hard-won victory within the authorities’s efforts to reorient a creaky forms towards a quickly evolving homegrown menace. On his first day in workplace, Trump erased that work by granting clemency to greater than 1,500 Jan. 6 defendants, declaring an finish to “a grave nationwide injustice.”
Rhodes, sporting a Trump 2020 cap, was again in Washington with fellow “J6ers” inside hours of his launch within the early hours of Jan. 21, 2025 . Within the frigid air outdoors “the gulag,” because the D.C. Jail is understood on this crowd, he was swarmed by TV cameras and supporters providing congratulations. Close by, far-right Proud Boys members puffed cigars. A speaker blared Bob Marley’s “Redemption Tune.”
“It’s surreal,” Rhodes mentioned, absorbing the scene.
Credit score:
Kent Nishimura/Getty Photographs
The shock of the second has continued to reverberate far past the jailhouse parking zone.
Trump’s pardons instantly upended the most important single prosecution in U.S. historical past and signaled a broader reversal that threatens to create a extra permissive local weather through which extremists might regroup, weaken the FBI’s independence and revive outdated debates about who counts as a terrorist, in line with present and former federal regulation enforcement officers and nationwide safety specialists.
Within the whirlwind of the final three weeks, the Trump administration has purged federal regulation enforcement companies of prosecutors and investigators who’d been pursuing homegrown far-right teams that the FBI lists as among the many most harmful threats to nationwide safety. The Biden administration’s 2021 home terrorism technique — the nation’s first — was faraway from the White Home web site. And a few government-funded extremism-prevention packages had been ordered to cease work.
“There’s no indication that he engaged in any form of evaluation or has even stopped to suppose, ‘What did I simply unleash on America?’” Mary McCord, a former federal prosecutor who oversaw home terrorism circumstances as a senior Justice Division official, mentioned of Trump’s actions.
Colin Clarke, an analyst on the nonpartisan security-focused Soufan Middle, mentioned “far proper” and “home terrorism” at the moment are “form of soiled phrases with the present administration.”
Far-right actions that brazenly promote violence have all of a sudden been invigorated, he mentioned. “Does this grow to be a four-year interval the place these teams can actually use the time to strengthen their group, their command and management, stockpile weapons?” he mentioned.
Credit score:
Kayla Bartkowski and Roberto Schmidt/AFP through Getty Photographs
A Sudden Departure
The adjustments are a departure even from the primary Trump White Home, which ramped up consideration on home terrorism in 2019 after assaults together with the lethal white supremacist rampage that August focusing on Latino buyers in El Paso, Texas.
The subsequent month, the Division of Homeland Safety issued a report that described home terrorism as a “rising menace,” that had “too often struck our homes of worship, our colleges, our workplaces, our festivals, and our buying areas.”
Joe Biden made violent extremism a central theme of his 2020 presidential marketing campaign, saying that he’d been impressed to run for workplace by a white supremacist rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, that turned violent, leaving one individual useless. His administration’s steps borrowed from earlier campaigns to fight AIDS and framed radicalization as a public well being precedence. Biden additionally made efforts to deal with extremism within the ranks of the navy and Division of Homeland Safety.
Consultants described the hassle as modest, however the strikes had been welcomed amongst counterterrorism specialists as an overdue corrective to a disproportionate deal with Islamist militant teams whose menace to the USA has receded within the many years because the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist assaults by al-Qaida.
A failure of authorities to pivot to the homegrown menace was cited within the findings of a Senate panel that examined intelligence missteps forward of the Capitol assault. The report known as for a reevaluation of the federal government’s evaluation of home threats, discovering that, “Neither the FBI nor DHS deemed on-line posts calling for violence on the Capitol as credible.”
This Trump administration has proven no urge for food for such measures. As an alternative, the White Home pardons are nudging fringe actions deeper into the mainstream and nearer to energy, mentioned Cynthia Miller-Idriss, who leads an extremism analysis lab at American College and has testified earlier than Congress in regards to the menace.
“It creates instant nationwide safety dangers from people who find themselves pledging revenge and retribution and who’ve now been valorized,” Miller-Idriss mentioned.
Inside 24 hours of his launch, Rhodes had launched into a comeback blitz. He visited the Capitol and stopped by a Dunkin’ Donuts within the Home workplace constructing. Three days later, he was in a crowd standing behind Trump at a rally in Las Vegas.
Rhodes was amongst 14 defendants whose costs had been commuted slightly than being pardoned. Although he didn’t enter the Capitol on Jan. 6, he was convicted of orchestrating the Oath Keepers’ violent actions that day. At trial, prosecutors performed a recording of him saying, “My solely remorse is they need to have introduced rifles.”
On the Capitol after his launch, he instructed reporters he plans to hunt a full pardon.
Extremists Reconnect, Rejoice on X
Emboldened by the pardons and Trump’s laser deal with mass deportations, which is redirecting authorities’ consideration, far-right extremists rejoiced on the thought of getting extra space to prepare.
Chat boards full of would-be MAGA vigilantes who fantasize about rounding up Democratic politicians or performing as bounty hunters to corral undocumented migrants. Researchers famous one Proud Boys chat group the place customers had posted the LinkedIn pages of corrections officers who purportedly oversaw Jan. 6 detainees.
Newly freed prisoners, not topic to orders to avoid extremists and co-defendants, gathered for a digital reunion, hosted on Elon Musk’s X platform the weekend after their launch. For hours, they talked about what led them to the Capitol, how they had been taken into custody and the cruel jail situations they confronted — a vivid, albeit one-sided, oral historical past of life on the heart of what the Justice Division had hailed as a landmark home terrorism investigation.
The reunion on X provided a glimpse of males juggling the joys of their vindication with the mundane logistics of reintegrating to society. One former defendant known as in from a Florida shopping center the place he was shopping for sneakers along with his mother. A Montana man who embraces the QAnon conspiracy concept mentioned he was experiencing probably the most thrilling time of his life.
Some had been too flustered to articulate their ideas past a deep gratitude for God and Trump. Others sounded fired up, able to run for workplace, be part of a class-action lawsuit over their prosecution or discover others methods to, as one pardoned rioter put it, “struggle the hell out of this factor.”
What We’re Watching
Throughout Donald Trump’s second presidency, ProPublica will deal with the areas most in want of scrutiny. Listed below are among the points our reporters will likely be watching — and how one can get in contact with them securely.
We’re making an attempt one thing new. Was it useful?
Exterior the D.C. Jail, pardoned defendants described the whiplash of their sudden standing change from alleged and convicted criminals to freed patriots.
William Sarsfield III, a tall, gray-bearded man in a camouflage cap printed with “Biden Sucks,” sipped espresso outdoors the jail. Earlier than daybreak that morning, he’d been launched from a Philadelphia detention heart the place he was awaiting sentencing on felony and misdemeanor convictions.
Courtroom papers, backed by video proof, describe Sarsfield as becoming a member of different Capitol rioters in making an attempt to push via a police line with such power that “one officer might be heard screaming in agonizing ache as he was smashed between a defend and a metallic door body.” Sarsfield insists the costs had been inflated, noting that he additionally helped officers escape the mob that day.
Within the runup to Trump’s inauguration, rumors had swirled about an imminent pardon, although particulars had been fuzzy. Sarsfield mentioned his girlfriend was so sure Trump would ship that she hopped in a truck and raced from Gun Barrel Metropolis, an hour southeast of Dallas, to the jail in Philadelphia, a 22-hour drive.
“She drove all the best way from Texas on religion,” he mentioned. “As a result of we each knew it was going to be proper. A person’s phrase is what his phrase is.”
After his launch, Sarsfield mentioned, he headed straight to the D.C. “gulag” to verify others had been getting out, too. He nonetheless wore his jail uniform of sweats and orange slippers. The miracle of his freedom was simply starting to sink in.
“I acquired pardoned by a felon,” Sarsfield mentioned with an incredulous chuckle, referring to Trump’s distinction as the one U.S. president to serve after a felony conviction.
Sarsfield mentioned he deliberate to point out his appreciation by serving to Trump “clear up in native communities,” which he mentioned meant working on the grassroots degree to reveal prosecutors and politicians he believes have corrupted the justice system.
“When folks determine to not use the rule of regulation, that turns into tyrannical,” Sarsfield mentioned. “And in our Structure I’m fairly certain it says when tyranny turns into regulation, rise up turns into responsibility.”
Credit score:
Kayla Bartkowski/Getty Photographs
An “Inflection Level” for Political Violence
The uncertainty of what comes subsequent is nerve-wracking for longtime displays of violent extremists. Even of their worst-case eventualities, they mentioned, few foresaw the Trump administration sending lots of of diehard election deniers again into their communities as aggrieved heroes.
“Loads of these folks can have martyrdom or legendary standing amongst extremist circles, and that could be a very highly effective recruiting device,” mentioned Kieran Doyle, North America analysis supervisor for the Armed Battle Location & Occasion Knowledge Challenge, a world battle monitoring group.
ACLED analysis exhibits extremist exercise corresponding to demonstrations and acts of political violence has declined since 2023, which noticed a 35% discount in mobilization in comparison with the earlier 12 months. Doyle and different displays credit score the drop partially to the chilling impact of the Justice Division’s post-Jan. 6 crackdown on anti-government and white supremacist actions.
Doyle cautioned that it’s too early to evaluate the ripple impact of Trump’s clemency on extremist exercise. Their capacity to regroup depends upon a number of components, together with worry of FBI infiltration, which might subside now that hard-right Trump loyalists are overseeing the Justice Division.
“We’re at an inflection level,” Doyle mentioned.
On the FBI, the Trump administration’s post-clemency vows of payback have sidelined a cohort of senior officers who oversaw the Jan. 6 portfolio of circumstances, ensuing within the lack of among the bureau’s most seasoned counterterrorism professionals.
With out that experience, investigators run the danger of violating a suspect’s civil rights or, conversely, overlooking threats as a result of they’re assumed to be constitutionally protected, mentioned a veteran FBI analyst who has labored on Jan. 6 circumstances.
“It has the potential to chop each methods,” the analyst mentioned, talking on situation of anonymity for worry of retribution.
Many longtime displays of extremist actions have themselves grow to be targets of threats and violence from Jan. 6 defendants and their supporters, elevating anxiousness about their launch from jail.
Megan Squire, a pc scientist who in 2017 was among the many first educational researchers documenting the Proud Boys’ more and more organized violence, mentioned members are already “saber-rattling and reconstituting useless chapters.”
The group’s former chief, Enrique Tarrio, launched from jail in Louisiana, instructed the far-right Infowars podcast: “Success goes to be retribution.”
Credit score:
Graeme Sloan/Bloomberg/Getty Photographs
All 5 Proud Boys charged with seditious conspiracy in reference to the Capitol assault had been in Squire’s unique dataset. One other member who was a Jan. 6 defendant had beforehand blasted Squire on social media and posted her personal info on Telegram.
Squire, who has since joined the civil rights-focused Southern Poverty Legislation Middle, mentioned she finds herself questioning, “Are they going to come back after me now?”
