James Franklin Fired: What’s Next for Penn State Football?
On October 12, 2023, the Penn State Nittany Lions announced the firing of football coach James Franklin, a move that is set to have significant implications on this year’s coaching carousel. Franklin’s tenure has been a rollercoaster ride, filled with moments of high achievement and frustrating lows. The decision to part ways comes after a disappointing season, characterized by a three-game losing streak that saw Penn State fall from a preseason No. 2 ranking in the US LBM Coaches Poll to a more sobering reality.
A Shaky 2023 Season
The season took a turn for the worse when the Nittany Lions suffered an overtime loss to Oregon on September 27. This setback was followed by two more heartbreaking losses—one against UCLA, which had yet to register a win, and another against unranked Northwestern. Each loss piled on the frustration for both fans and the program, ultimately leading to Franklin’s departure.
Franklin was appointed head coach before the 2014 season and leaves the program with a commendable 104-45 record. However, his inability to succeed against elite teams—evidenced by a dismal 4-21 record versus top-10 opponents—has left many questioning his recruiting and game strategies. To compound matters, Penn State is also without its quarterback, Drew Allar, who has been sidelined for the season due to a significant injury suffered against Northwestern.
Potential Coaching Candidates
With Franklin’s exit, the spotlight now shifts to potential candidates who could lead the Nittany Lions back to a winning trajectory. The coaching hunt will certainly generate buzz across the college football landscape.
Matt Rhule, Nebraska
Rhule, a Penn State linebacker from 1994 to 1997, is currently in his third season at Nebraska, boasting a 5-1 record. As a former head coach for the Carolina Panthers, he possesses a robust track record for turning struggling programs around, notably at Temple and Baylor. His long-standing friendship with Penn State athletics director Pat Kraft adds another layer of interest. Nevertheless, Rhule’s mixed performance against ranked teams may raise eyebrows among Nittany Lions fans who have become accustomed to high-stakes competition.
Matt Campbell, Iowa State
The head coach at Iowa State since 2016, Campbell has built a perennial Big 12 contender. With two top-15 finishes and numerous NFL talent under his belt, including Brock Purdy and Breece Hall, Campbell is a sought-after coach with a solid reputation. His successful program-building record makes him a strong candidate for the Penn State role, especially if he can leverage top-tier resources to steer the Nittany Lions back into contention.
Curt Cignetti, Indiana
Currently leading Indiana to what has been a historic season, Cignetti has compiled a 17-2 record and is credited with turning the Hoosiers into a national title contender. His team’s physical play and strategic prowess make him an attractive candidate. Cignetti’s earlier coaching experience, including a successful stint at James Madison, illustrates a pattern of success that Penn State may look to replicate.
Manny Diaz, Duke
Having served as Penn State’s defensive coordinator from 2022 to 2023, Diaz has recently taken the helm at Duke, achieving a 13-6 record so far. Though some may consider him a connection to the Franklin era, his understanding of the Penn State program could serve as an asset. Still, skepticism around his earlier tenure at Miami may impact his candidacy.
Jon Sumrall, Tulane
Currently in his second year at Tulane, Sumrall offers a defensive background that could align with Penn State’s culture. While his ties to the SEC could present a challenge, his strong foundational skills may earn him an interview. However, given his relatively recent entry into the head coaching arena, he might not be the frontrunner.
Brent Key, Georgia Tech
Key has seen Georgia Tech rise in the rankings due to a focused and disciplined approach. Like Franklin during his time at Vanderbilt, Key’s potential for success with greater resources is an intriguing angle for the Nittany Lions. His pragmatic approach could stabilize the program post-Franklin.
Mike Elko, Texas A&M
Elko has a robust position at Texas A&M, steadily guiding his team towards SEC competition. However, the promise of a more straightforward path to playoff contention at Penn State might warrant a conversation. His caliber as a coach places him firmly within the list of serious contenders for the Nittany Lions’ head coach role.
Alex Golesh, South Florida
Golesh has garnered attention after leading South Florida to a promising start, including a recent win against North Texas. With a growing reputation in the Group of Five, his offensive background makes him an intriguing option for the Nittany Lions, even if his experience level is a point of concern.
Fran Brown, Syracuse
In just his second year at Syracuse, Brown has already made an impression, guiding the team to a 10-3 record last season. His coaching tenure is marked by a defensive focus, and his time with various programs under Rhule has provided him with valuable experience. Although limited, his strong start at Syracuse positions him as a candidate who could surprise in the coaching search.
As Penn State enters a new chapter without James Franklin, the landscape is buzzing with possibilities. The next head coach will undoubtedly shape the future of this storied program, and fans are eagerly awaiting the decision that will set the course for the Nittany Lions.