Celebrating Diversity in Christmas: The Black Santa Phenomenon
As Christmas decorations adorn homes across the globe, the representation of Black Santas remains remarkably scarce. However, in Central Texas, Dr. Bess Carpenter Dunner has been crafting her own oasis of diversity through an impressive collection that she has curated over several decades. This heartwarming initiative not only spreads joy but also highlights the importance of representation in holiday traditions.
A Collection That Tells a Story
“People walk into my house for the first time and are astounded,” Dunner shared in a conversation with KWTX in Waco, Texas. Her home, filled with nearly 2,000 Black Santa figurines, captivates visitors with its authentic representation of what Santa Claus can look like. For Dunner, the presence of these figurines reflects her own identity. “My response to them is, but I am too. So, my Santas look like me,” she quipped.
Dunner’s collection is not just a display; it’s a vibrant narrative played out through her figurines. Spread throughout her house—on counters, bookshelves, hallways, and bedrooms—these Santas tell stories of family, culture, and the essence of Christmas through her eyes.
An Investment in Heritage
The time and money Dunner has invested into this collection are significant. Over the years, as the demand for Black Santa figurines has increased, she notes a marked rise in their prices. “Even last year this one was $49 and this year it’s $89,” she remarked, emphasizing both the financial and emotional layers of her collecting journey.
Dunner also keeps the original price tags on some Santas for a reason—to provide her children a tangible understanding of how value and perception can change over time. This effort isn’t merely about owning figures; it embodies a legacy of memories and lessons that she hopes to pass down.
The Allure of Handcrafted Collectibles
Dunner has a particular affinity for the Department 56 Possible Dreams collection, known for its handcrafted and hand-painted ceramic pieces. Each item in this limited collection is unique; once sold out, they aren’t restocked, making each piece even more special. The labor and artistry behind these Santas enhance their value in Dunner’s eyes, transforming them from mere decorations into cherished heirlooms.
The Origins of Black Santa
The concept of a Black Santa is rooted in a complex history. Emerging in the early 1900s, Black men portraying Santa were often met with racist skepticism. Among these experiences stands out the mockery faced by Black Santa performers at a Christmas dinner hosted by President Woodrow Wilson. However, a significant shift occurred thanks to iconic figures like Bill “Bojangles” Robinson, who donned the red suit for holiday events in Harlem, thus popularizing the idea within Black communities across America. This evolution highlights a profound need for representation in the context of holiday celebrations.
Contemporary Perspectives
Today, the representation of Black Santas still ignites debate. In San Antonio, for example, one onlooker referred to James Hudson, a local Santa, as “woke Santa” with mixed reactions. Hudson, who identifies as Santa James, embraces the role as a means of embodying the values associated with Christmas: generosity, love, and joy. “Our joy is not limited to a skin tone,” he stated confidently, underscoring the inclusive spirit that the figure of Santa Claus can represent.
Joy in Representation
The experiences of both Dunner and Hudson echo a broader sentiment in celebrating Christmas. Their efforts symbolize not just a personal tradition but a cultural awakening that recognizes the need for varied representation. The movement towards more inclusive holiday figures serves as a reminder that joy, hope, and the spirit of giving transcend appearances and skin tones.
In an age where discussions on representation are more vital than ever, the celebration of Black Santas reflects an ongoing journey toward inclusivity that enriches the holiday experience for everyone. From homes adorned with diverse figurines to communities cheering on Santas of various backgrounds, the presence of Black Santas is gradually changing how Christmas is visualized and celebrated in modern America.