2025 Heisman Spotlight: Fernando Mendoza and Indiana’s Historic Season

If betting odds are to be believed, Indiana’s Fernando Mendoza wrapped up the 2025 Heisman Trophy last Saturday with a spectacular 222-yard performance in the Hoosiers’ historic 13-10 win over the Ohio State Buckeyes in the Big Ten Championship. This victory has not only solidified Mendoza’s status as a frontrunner but also catapulted Indiana into the national spotlight.

The Heisman Race Unfolds

In the gripping race for the prestigious Heisman Trophy, Mendoza isn’t just the sole name in contention. Based on my weekly Heisman race columns, Vanderbilt’s Diego Pavia also deserves recognition for his outstanding performance throughout the season. While he was named a finalist, Mendoza’s game against Ohio State may very well define this year’s trophy outlook. Alongside Mendoza and Pavia, competitors include Ohio State’s Julian Sayin and Notre Dame’s Jeremiyah Love, both of whom will be honored at the Heisman ceremony on Saturday.

Celebrating College Football’s Alternative Awards

While the Heisman often takes center stage, various other awards highlight different aspects of college football. This week’s “The Home Depot College Football Awards” ceremony will see honors like the Biletnikoff Award for the best receiver, Bednarik Award for outstanding defensive player, and more. Yet, it’s time to recognize some lesser-known but equally deserving accolades in college football. Thus, we present alternative awards that celebrate players who have made their mark in unique ways.

The Dog in Him Award

One of the most interesting and innovative awards this year is the “Dog in Him Award,” which celebrates the quarterbacks who display tenacity, physicality, and the ability to improvise. This award recognizes players who take hits, make big plays on the run, and exemplify the spirit of the game.

1. Diego Pavia, Vanderbilt – Securing the top spot for the second consecutive year, Pavia has led an impressive turnaround for Vanderbilt, showcasing not just skill but also the “dog” mentality. His ability to make plays with both his arms and legs has defined his game this season.

2. Blake Horvath, Navy – Recognized for his outstanding performance, Horvath has been pivotal in Navy’s offensive gameplan, adding an element of surprise and physicality to the field.

3. Haynes King, Georgia Tech – King’s resilience and dynamic playstyle earned him a well-deserved third place. His ability to shake off tackles and lead his team through tough situations has been commendable.

Journeyman of the Year

In an era dominated by the transfer portal, the “Journeyman of the Year” recognizes athletes who have navigated their college careers across multiple programs. This year’s standout is:

• Romello Height, Texas Tech – Height has transformed into a playmaker after transferring from Auburn, demonstrating his skill in a new environment and significantly contributing to Texas Tech’s success.

YAC King

While quarterbacks often steal the limelight, the “YAC King” award brings attention to running backs who excel after contact.

1. Ahmad Hardy, Missouri – With an impressive 1,107 yards after contact, Hardy’s physical style of running has made him a key player for Missouri, where he consistently churns out yards.

2. Cam Cook, Jacksonville State – Known for his explosiveness and consistency, Cook has emerged as a significant threat in his team’s running game, proving invaluable in tight contests.

3. Hollywood Smothers, NC State – Despite facing challenges, Smothers made a significant impact with his ability to evade tackles, showcasing grit and determination throughout the season.

Havoc King

Defense wins championships, and recognizing the Havoc Kings of the gridiron illuminates those players who disrupt offensive plays:

1. Jacob Rodriguez, Texas Tech – A defensive powerhouse, Rodriguez has caused chaos on opposing offenses with his remarkable ability to force turnovers and create havoc plays.

2. Nadame Tucker, Western Michigan – Having transitioned from a reserve role to a key defensive cog, Tucker’s contribution has transformed his team’s defensive unit.

3. David Bailey, Texas Tech – Playing alongside Rodriguez, Bailey has proven to be a formidable force in disrupting plays and turning potential gains into negative yardage.

Hard Job Coach of the Year

The coaching aspect in college football deserves recognition too. Some coaches work miracles in challenging circumstances. This year’s standout is:

• Jason Eck, New Mexico – Eck’s ability to resurrect a struggling program shows how impactful a capable coach can be. Under his guidance, New Mexico experienced a remarkable turnaround, pushing for a near 10-win season.

Key Moments in 2025 College Football

Catch of the Year

Highlight plays are a staple of football, and the “Catch of the Year” award promises to bring attention to unforgettable moments.

1. Omar Cooper Jr. (Indiana) vs. Penn State – Cooper’s gravity-defying catch was not merely a highlight but a defining moment that kept Indiana on their path to becoming a top playoff seed.

2. CJ Daniels (Miami) vs. Notre Dame – A critical catch that not only secured a former high-stakes game but also showcased Daniels’ willingness to make the game-altering plays.

3. KJ Duff (Rutgers) vs. Penn State – Duff’s one-handed snag against a formidable opponent is a testament to the athleticism and skill that makes college football so captivating.

Your New Favorite Small-School Offense

Among the lesser-known programs, offensive experiments pop up that redefine expectations.

• Wisconsin-River Falls – With a remarkable scoring average and a high-octane offense, UWRF has caught the eye of college football fans, blending creative playcalling with superb execution.

The 2025 college football season is undoubtedly memorable, filled with exceptional talent and unforgettable moments. As we await the Heisman ceremony, the excitement surrounding alternative awards and stand-out performances continues to fuel our passion for the sport.